Stop Obama In 2010
The Other Public Option (Is a Failure)
Its The End of the Road for What Barack and I Are Trying to Do
The final bill could be even worse for your family and America
IF OBAMA'S HEALTHCARE BILLS GETS ENOUGH VOTES...
ENERGY TAX: Cap-and-Trade Largest Tax Increase in U.S. History
Obama's Enemies List Grows
POLL: Do You Miss President Bush Yet
Energy Tax - CAP and TRADE to cost families $1,761 a year
Joe Wilson As Tea Party Keynote Speaker
Americans Working Together
November 1, 2009 TEA PARTY
Is Barack Hussein Obama a closet racist?
Sen. Russ Feingold (D-Wis.) scolded the White House for not showing up to an oversight hearing
What's going to happen in 2010
This is how the Congress will pass ObamaCare.
Top 10 Reasons Chicago Lost Olympic Bid
Among the $500 billion in Medicare cuts...
Stop Obama's Gun Free America: Paul Broun U.S. Congressman
Obama's New Board Game To End Capitalism
What Is This Democrat Governor Afraid Of...?
Is Obama Confused About His Priorities
RECALL OBAMA: If there was a legal way to RECALL Obama would you vote to RECALL him from President
Congressman Reminds Americans of the Failure of Another Public Option
The Other Public Option (Is a Failure)
SHOCK VIDEO: School kids taught to praise Obama...
Illegal Alien Amnesty is back, and with a vengeance
Vile, left wing propaganda video being shown at US public schools
Do You Want America's School Children To Be Shown This Video
Obama Wants To Legalize Illegals To Get Them Health Care
America's Freedom Tea Parties Are Growing
Democrat Governor is blocking a corruption investigation of his Office of Attorney Ethics
 
Read what happened when a different Public Option was voted in...
 
 
The Other Public Option  
Comments from Congressman Scott Garrett
 

Since 1965, private loans carrying a federal guarantee have been the most common means of borrowing to finance a college education.  It took less than two decades for the public option to crowd out private student loan providers, leaving students, parents, and universities with an “option” that they have rejected by a two-to-one margin. 

The idea that government can compete with private health insurance – while setting its own rules for competition – and remain optional defies both history and basic economic principles.  I support real health care reform that is portable, affordable, sustainable, effective, and innovative. Please feel free to share your thoughts on this issue with my office at 202-225-4465.

Sincerely,

Scott Garrett
Member of Congress

 

Read Congressman Garrett's full comments below.

 
 
 
The Other Public Option  
September 24, 2009


In 1993, Congressional Democrats worked with newly sworn-in President Bill Clinton to create the William D. Ford Federal Direct Loan Program, a student loan public option meant to compete with private student loan issuers.  “We are not taking a free enterprise system and federalizing it,” then-Deputy Education Secretary Madeleine Kunin said.  “We are…improving the entrepreneurial and competitive possibilities.”  Sound familiar?

Fast forward sixteen years and the new Congressional majority is again working with a newly installed President on a public option, this time a public option for health care insurance.  President Obama’s chief ally in the Senate, Dick Durbin, said on Meet The Press last Sunday that this public option is a way to make sure there's competition for these private health insurance companies.  The President himself has said that the public option will force the insurance companies to compete and keep them honest.

The student loan public option should serve as a cautionary and instructional tale for Congress and the American people as we continue to discuss ways to reform the health care system.  Right now, over 80% of student loans issues are federally guaranteed – about two-thirds of those are issued through private lenders, while the remaining third are secured directly through the public option.  Though both public lenders and federally guaranteed private lenders offer relatively similar interest rates and payment plans, more than twice as many students and parents choose private options because of universities’ preference and superior customer service.

On Thursday, the House passed a bill (H.R. 3221) that will, if signed into law, eliminate private loans with federal guarantees, replacing such loans entirely with the government’s Direct Loan program – in other words, removing the optionality of the public option – at a cost of $1 trillion over the next ten years.  In addition to crowding private capital out of the industry, this bill gives the public student loan programs advantages the private sector will be unable to match.  For example, the bill gives federal loans a variable interest rate when rates are on the decline and a cap when rates go back up.  The plan also locks in low fixed-interest rates on certain loans.  Once the Federal Reserve’s spending spree results in unavoidable inflation, the Treasury will likely be paying to lend this money.  All of these provisions lead to an unsustainable plan described by the Wall Street Journal as a kind of heads-borrowers-win, tails-taxpayers-lose offer [that] will be difficult for a private company to match.

Since 1965, private loans carrying a federal guarantee have been the most common means of borrowing to finance a college education.  It took less than two decades for the public option to crowd out private student loan providers, leaving students, parents, and universities with an “option” that they have rejected by a two-to-one margin. 

The idea that government can compete with private health insurance – while setting its own rules for competition – and remain optional defies both history and basic economic principles.  I support real health care reform that is portable, affordable, sustainable, effective, and innovative. Please feel free to share your thoughts on this issue with my office at 202-225-4465.

Sincerely,

Scott Garrett
Member of Congress

OFFICE LOCATIONS

Washington, DC
137 Cannon HOB
Washington, DC 20515
Phone: (202) 225-4465
Fax: (202) 225-9048

Eastern District Office
266 Harristown Rd, Suite 104
Glen Rock, NJ 07452
Phone: (201) 444-5454
Fax: (201) 444-5488

Western District Office
93 Main Street
Newton, NJ 07860
Phone: (973) 300-2000
Fax: (973) 300-1051

 
"Support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign or domestic"
Oaths of military enlisted and all government officials
 
 
 
Please ask Congressman Scott Garrett to support disabled veteran John "Jack" Cunningham in his battle to stop a political cover-up in the congressman's own Congressional district.  Congressman Garrett's staff are completely aware of the problem.   Please call him at:   202-225-4465
Details are at the next link.
 
 
Democrat Governor is blocking a corruption investigation of his Office of Attorney Ethics